diff --git a/apps/red-ui/src/app/modules/file-preview/dialogs/edit-redaction-dialog/edit-redaction-dialog.component.ts b/apps/red-ui/src/app/modules/file-preview/dialogs/edit-redaction-dialog/edit-redaction-dialog.component.ts
index 123006f92..7cee4dbe2 100644
--- a/apps/red-ui/src/app/modules/file-preview/dialogs/edit-redaction-dialog/edit-redaction-dialog.component.ts
+++ b/apps/red-ui/src/app/modules/file-preview/dialogs/edit-redaction-dialog/edit-redaction-dialog.component.ts
@@ -26,8 +26,8 @@ export class EditRedactionDialogComponent
     readonly isImage: boolean;
     readonly isManualRedaction: boolean;
     readonly isHint: boolean;
+    readonly isRedacted: boolean;
     readonly allRectangles = this.data.annotations.reduce((acc, a) => acc && a.AREA, true);
-    readonly showExtras: boolean;
     options: DetailsRadioOption<RedactOrHintOption>[] | undefined;
     legalOptions: LegalBasisOption[] = [];
     dictionaries: Dictionary[] = [];
@@ -44,8 +44,7 @@ export class EditRedactionDialogComponent
         this.isModifyDictionary = annotations.every(annotation => annotation.isModifyDictionary);
         this.isManualRedaction = annotations.every(annotation => annotation.type === SuperTypes.ManualRedaction);
         this.isHint = annotations.every(annotation => annotation.HINT);
-        const isRedacted = annotations.every(annotation => annotation.isRedacted);
-        this.showExtras = !((this.isImage && !isRedacted) || this.isHint);
+        this.isRedacted = annotations.every(annotation => annotation.isRedacted);
     }
 
     get displayedDictionaryLabel() {
@@ -104,6 +103,8 @@ export class EditRedactionDialogComponent
         const selectedDictionaryType = this.form.controls.type.value;
         this.#setOptions(selectedDictionaryType);
 
+        console.log(this.redactBasedTypes);
+        console.log(selectedDictionaryType);
         if (this.redactBasedTypes.includes(selectedDictionaryType)) {
             this.form.controls.reason.enable();
         } else {
@@ -162,4 +163,10 @@ export class EditRedactionDialogComponent
             value: new FormControl<string>(this.allRectangles ? this.data.annotations[0].value : null),
         });
     }
+
+    get showExtras() {
+        const type = this.form.get('type').value;
+        const isSignature = type === 'signature';
+        return (isSignature && this.isRedacted) || !(this.isImage || this.isHint);
+    }
 }